Why did dobby have to die reddit. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Why? He was a minor character. Then everything could play out the exact same way while avoiding the necessity of Harry holding the Idiot Ball. It's just that in the future she goes to the safe and types in the password. In Through the looking glass 2 when eye patch dude blows a grenade Charlie locks himself inside the radio room and drowns. It was literally someone’s house pet that escaped, and they go in and end up just brutalizing it while Hank says “tell Bobby we let the snake go in a… Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. 1 day later and I still have Kaori and the April ost stuck in my head. Harry should have lied and then Dobby could still smash the pudding "just to be safe". He literally couldn't spot one when he held it in his hand. Dobby's sacrifice is one of the most heartbreaking in the Harry Potter saga and proves just how loyal Dobby was to Harry until the end. Reply reply More replies More replies More replies Donnie doesn't have to die, it's just what his destiny was and couldn't deviate from it. Ultimately though, I know why Hedwig had to die knowing the story, but it still seemed a bit unnecessary to me. Because he broke his promise to never try to save Harry's life again. Most deaths happen in the middle of other things happening. He came to know this via the contact between his masters and Lord Voldemort. Hebrews 9:21 In the same way, Moses sprinkled the blood on the Holy Tent and over all the things used in worship. True, the scene lacks emotion becausy Dobby hadn' t appeared for so long. Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? Mar 10, 2024 · As a show of respect and a way of repaying everything Dobby did to help him, Harry buries Dobby without the use of magic at Bill and Fleur's home, Shell Cottage. Main characters don’t die often enough tbf. Dobby was so injured that he couldn't have possibly taken any action to save himself. A Tumblr user (in a now-deleted post) suggested that the one who killed Hedwig was Severus Snape, and he did so in order to keep Harry safe. What she used on Ron was essence of dittany, which I don't think is as effective for very serious injuries. They didn't need to die. It's like so annoying, and the real reason i could see why they cut him out of the following films we'll discuss, is because they really didn't know any better, or better yet didn't know he would become such a huge and important character later down the line. That's all my opinion though. At the end of that school year, after Harry had In deathly hallows, the scene where they were all escaping from Malfoy manor with Dobby’s help, and bellatrix throws a knife as they were disapparating, as they get to the cottage where Bill and Fleur were staying in, Harry discovers dobby was stabbed (I’ve always wondered why the knife didn’t get to the goblin instead, anyways) He’s frantically trying to save the little elf and looks Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Nov 16, 2021 · Redditor VMNC presents another unpopular perspective when he states that Dobby's death was necessary for the plot to make sense. It is the Son showing the greatest love ever known to satisfy perfect holy justice. It makes the story too predictable because whenever they then introduce new cast, it’s pretty guaranteed they’re gonna die within a couple eps because they just suck the life out of boring, undeveloped characters. If Dobby spent the entirety of CoS living with Harry and constantly bumbling about saying, "Doh, did Dobby do that?" Then he probably would've been much harder to like later on. His influence will continue on through the friendships he formed and the strength he gave them, which will then influence others, in perpetuity. Aug 4, 2019 · Dobby is one of many characters to leave a lasting impact on the fans. Dec 25, 2018 · In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co. The main cast is way too big and there isn’t enough character development. I've been reading the series and have gotten to the part in Goblet when Dobby states he looked for work for 2 years. With him alive, Harry and Company had free recon and communication with the rest of the Order, so he had to die. The house-elf's character came to his logical conclusion. "I was trying to make a world in which he (Teddy) could live a happier life. So what techniques did JK Rowling used to get the most out of our emotions for his death? Dobby is innocent, childlike. Harry actually did tell Dobby not to die: "Dobby, no, don't die, don't die" I think elf magic, though powerful, is limited. There’s no way an elf would have testified in court against the family while in their employ. I don't think I'm getting over this for a while. All of these things combined meant she couldn't help. His masters were Dark wizards who treated him cruelly. I don't see why Rowling couldn't have given Dobby to the Weasleys. It says so win the book while he's digging the grave. The oddest outcome was to just kill himself and trust that Gus and Mike protect his father. Being a demon is kinda lame though, even if you disregard the morality issues. And of course, they wouldn't try to keep it a secret from Dobby, because in their eyes he was nothing more than filth. Like, it’s the saddest death in the series IMO because he was so pure and had finally found some happiness after years of misery. " Mike was going to kill Walt right then and there in the laundry. And it's doubtful he would have listened to Dobby's story if Dobby did survive - Regulus apparently cared about Kreacher, but Lucius was horrible to Dobby. Jun 20, 2018 · @AnthonyGrist Dobby was ultimately trying to help Harry (by keeping him safe from danger). Dobby is trying to stop Harry from going back to Hogwarts, telling him that bad things are going to happen there. He allowed all this to happen knowing that he didn't have to go through with it (he was sinless and therefore not deserving of the punishment) and that he could have gotten out of it if he wanted to, and that he was doing it all for others who would deny and mock him, and yet he still did it. Jesus paid for a penalty He did not deserve to pay a debt we were not worthy to pay. He had to do something drastic immediately. That's the thing, Makoto did have a happy ending. . A psychiatrist forcibly restraining and sedating a manic patient who wants to hurl himself off a high ledge (because he thinks he can fly like Superman) is still trying to help the patient (by keeping him alive) even though the patient may disagree in his current (manic) state of mind. • 2 yr. If they’d known they’d have to get an emotional moment out of his death in movie 7, they surely would have used him more. Malfoys obviously knew that the chamber has been opened by Voldemort before, 50 years ago, and that the diary will help open it again. But, also, she was barely able to stand after what happened to her in Malfoy Manor. True he did promise that like book 2 or maybe 1 cake scene with his aunt. It was probably worth it, seeing as he probably would have destroyed everybody else. So when Dobby does die on book 7 it is SOUL CRUSHING. That's not romantic, but it's true from a writing standpoint. Dobby, is practically everyone's favorite character, yet he really gets the short end of the stick in the films. It's a shame that Harry didn't summon the Dittany from Hermione's beaded bag, though. That's how Dobby knew. And Remus and Tonks did die for a reason, at least according to Remus. Jan 29, 2022 · In-universe, however, fans have come up with different interpretations of why Hedwig had to die, especially in the movie, as the scene happened differently in the book and the movie. Sirius died in the middle of battle. Rowling apologized for killing off Dobby in "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. The plot can be written without him, so that’s what they did. With seven Harry If Jamis would have gone with the vow that Stilgar and the rest made with the cutting of the top of their wrist things could have worked put in much the same way as they did with Jamis death (with perhaps a little more time for Paul to prove himself to the rest of the fremen). That's a minor enough change that I wouldn't be worried about it. They shove Dobby back into the plot only so they can have a tearjerker moment at his They would have had to reconstruct major portions of the story structure if Glenn had lived. Oct 17, 2023 · Dobby's death scene is an emotional part of the film, resonating with the audience so much that people left socks in honor of Dobby at the filming location until it became an environmental hazard Sep 1, 2021 · Sirius and Dobby are not linked only because of their killer, but because of the mistreatment they suffered that is never fully redeemed. Dobby has a statue at Warner Brothers Studio that is incredibly lifelike, and visiting fans have been moved to leave a tribute. In The Deathly Hallows, Dobby sneaks into Malfoy Manor in order to save Harry, Ron Weasley Dobby (28 June (year unknown) – March 1998) was a male house-elf who served the Malfoy family. Dobby in fact did know best about Harry's personal safety. His death was especially heartbreaking and one of the most impactful moments of the entire seven-part story. He figured his own son was safe because he was a pureblood. It didn’t make sense to me either. As stated above, Dobby was an innocent soul that was lost in the shuffle of the struggle between good and evil. Dobby did not simply decide he knew best about Harry's personal safety. Of course they could have just used a human clone instead. Dobby's death is the saddest because they made us sit in it. Dobby would have become "a get-out-of-jail-free card for the entire rest of the plotline" and Harry and the others would have been able to communicate easily with the Order without the Death Eaters or Voldemort being able to trace them. In defense of the movies though, at the time they were filmed, the Deathly Hallows book wasn' t released yet, so the filmmakers couldn' t have known that Dobby would play a crucial part(and die) in DH. I mean, suppose your room-mate is heading out the door to work, and you happen to know for a fact that a coyote left a trap that'll drop an anvil on them the second they leave the door. No time to grieve, got to keep moving. Regardless of Lucas' original plans, Jar Jar's annoying antics ended up serving little purpose besides trying too hard to be funny. What an amazing God that we have… this is not some form of cosmic child abuse. The only other person I could see him killing himself by overthinking himself would probably have been Ichigo, but Ichigo would have been too late most likely. Jamis could have truly shown Paul the ways of the desert. Well seeing as Zaraki was probably the only person who could have beat imagination boy. Harry Potter was only a baby when he survived You could have had a scene where Murph "feels" his death. Presumably Dobby overheard Lucius talking about his plan to get rid of the incriminating diary & frame Mr. He died surrounded by his loved ones, after having lived his life as he wanted to. " She shouldn't. Getting him out of the state would have taken time, which he didn't have. K. They would have treated him like pure gold, and I know Mrs. ago. They could have left her at The Burrow with Ron's owl Pigwidgeon. And everyone who has lost someone wonders why they had to die, they didn't want them to die. People who are important to other people die because of where and who they were. Just like Hedwig. Dobby is trying to stop Harry getting caught up in Lucius’s to mess Arthur up with his plot with the diary, the basilisk and Ginny; Lucius actually doesn’t care very much at that stage whether Harry is or isn’t at Hogwarts; it’s only Dobby that seems concerned about that, which is why Dobby takes it upon himself to warn Harry even May 2, 2018 · J. After seven years of being a reliable ally in the battle against evil and a stalwart father figure to Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles), Bobby Singer (Jim Beaver) died after being shot by the Leviathan, Dick Roman (James Patrick Stewart). Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. The films? They ignore all of that build up and friendship and loyalty. It's already written that way. After learning about the importance of the Deathly Hallows, Harry Potter recounts a necklace that he saw upon the neck of Xenophilius Lovegood at Bill and Fleur's wedding - a necklace depicting the symbol of the Hallows. Before his death, I can’t remember the last time he appeared in the book, and even when he appeared, he didn’t do anything important/memorable. Nor do I think Lucius would have figured out what the horcrux was in the way Regulus did. ” Bobby had one of the most tragic deaths in the show. As far as coming from a writing standpoint, the Trio didn't have to bring Hedwig with them. He wanted to pay his respect and wished Dobby could have a funeral like Dumbledore. May not even have been effective on house elves. It would have been interesting if they didn't also kill Abraham there and kept him alive for half the war or so. Witness protection was an option or just leave with his father. LicentiousGhoul. Of all those Konoha losers why did Neji have to be the one to die when he was probably the strongest one outside Team 7 and had one of the most interesting backstories? Even if he did need to be killed off for the plot, I thought the manner in which he died was insulting to his character. So did Fred, Dumbledore, Tonks and Remus. Also, in the books, Dobby dies a lot quicker, I think. It kills the movie for me. Rowling had a very good reason for doing it. But Charlie had the chance to get out and lock the door from the outside. We can accept that pardon in faith and trust the work that Jesus did on our behalf. Dobby died because he'd be a get-out-of-jail-free card for the entire rest of the plotline. All the movies are done this way, to maximize their time efficiency. VMNC • 9 yr. But if you're going to (a) have him miraculously survive a black hole (out of his spaceship and then (b) somehow have him rescued by the Station, all because it built up to this reunion scene, we need more than a few minutes and then peacing out. Weasley would have appreciated the help with so many people to look after. But bad things don’t happen until later when Lucius Malfoy gives Ginny Tom Riddle’s diary and Ginny gets possessed. IMO the times where they did that never went well. Harry Potter 's author Mar 18, 2024 · How did Dobby die in Harry Potter? Dobby died from a knife in his chest thrown by Bellatrix Lestrange. Because his being alive would make the trio's lives too easy. We don't know that Walt would have gone through with killing Gale if Victor didn't pick him up and take him to the laundry facility, but in doing so, he forced his But Lucius likely did not know what was in the chamber, and of course he did not know the diary was a horcrux. Warner Bros. However I've accepted the fact that Kaori's death was meaningful as in it changed us all in how we should look at and treat ourselves and others in our lives and how we should value life itself. It was easy to omit him from movies 4, 5 Jan 2, 2023 · Despite being one of the best Harry Potter movies, there was one moment in Deathly Hallows Part 1 that was disappointing upon first viewing. Weasley, likely to Narcissa. 22 The law says that almost everything must be made clean by blood, and sins cannot be forgiven without blood to show death. You have to become a cannibal, you can't walk in the sun, you are controlled by Muzan who can kill you at will, you lose most of your memories and aren't yourself anymore, you have the demon slayers hunting you, and you'd probably go to hell after death. Had he lived his elf apparition would have gotten them into Hogwarts without triggering an alarm. Apr 24, 2023 · Hedwig's death came as a surprise to many in "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows," but J. It's not that she's smart and figures out where the safe is and the password to it. One of the most heartbreaking aspects of Dobby's death is Mar 26, 2023 · Dobby's Death Signified the Death of Innocence. , and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still. It was the right time for him to Dobby went out of his way to warn Harry Potter about the danger in the second book but he severely punished himself for doing so and did his best to not break any additional rules while doing it. Harry had a lot of respect for Dobby and considered him a friend and very brave. This is also why there was an elphant in the room. In 1992, he disobeyed his masters and tried to warn Harry Potter of the plot to have the Chamber of Secrets reopened. I listened to Richard Kelly and Jake Gyllenhaals commentary the other day and he points out that when donnie returns to October 2nd and he's laughing in bed, you can actually hear a panicked honking after Elizabeth is dropped off. He is not super relevant to the plot of book 4, 5, or 6. This is why Bian was able to steal high IQ cum. Feb 9, 2024 · Bobby Singer died in Supernatural season 7, episode 10, “Death’s Door. ryia mqk ftaq eui rxbvbs thwo ewtgja eekt thhxm bbfcn